Sunday, October 29, 2006

Ornithological debate

I had another eye-opening debate with our lawyer-cum-weekend babysitter after she asserted that chickens are not birds -- because they do not fly.

I had been putting all the birds on T's wooden animal squares together in one group, telling him they were all birds.



When I put the chicken (which was actually drawn rather like a rooster) in the group with the blue bird and owl, Katka pointed out matter-of-factly: "That's not a bird" - I guess out of concern that I would confuse Tíško.

"So what are they?" I asked. "Dogs? Worms? And what about ostriches and penguins?"

At that last question, she paused, and looked as if she had never thought of that before, how penguins and ostriches would fit into her bird paradigm.

After a moment's consideration, she said confidently: "Chickens are members of the non-flying bird family. Just like penguins and ostriches."

To be sure that there was not some strange Slovak distinction when it came to bird classification, I later asked Lena her opinion about these surprising statements.

"No," she said, as we were walking by the Dr. Martens shop down on Štefánikova, "That's just dumb!"

No comments:

Post a Comment